When I ordered the new MacBook Pro M1 Max, I had no idea what I’d gotten myself into. I figured, new MacBook, new monitor, thatβll be it.
Oh, how wrong I was.
Prelude
Having returned my Apple Developer Transition Kit in early 2021, I still had credit sitting there in my Developer Account, taunting me. But I wanted to wait until the very last moment (which would have been December 31st, 2021) to see what Apple might release until then. After the M1 Mac Mini came the M1 iMac, which was quite tempting to me, but I held out a little longer, and eventually Apple released the M1 Pro/Max MacBook Pros. Itβs then that I pulled the trigger, because no other product announcements followed.
I was actually hoping Apple might replace the iMac 27β 5k with an M1 Pro/Max variant at the end of 2021. Coming from the 27β Intel model from 2017, I really had my heart set on a direct replacement β that display is a dream.
It didnβt happen, though, so I moved on to the new MacBook Pros, knowing Iβd also have to get an external monitor if I wanted the best of two worlds – working at a desk, and working βon the goβ; my very old silver 20β Apple Cinema Display, which I still have stored in the basement, just wouldnβt do.
Choosing a MacBook Pro
As I donβt buy a new Mac every year and instead tend to hold on to them as long as I can (Iβd still continue to use my Intel iMac hadnβt Apple transitioned to Apple Silicon), I usually invest a little more into a new Mac, so my decision was to get the MacBook Pro M1 Max 16″ 10c/32c/16c/64GB/512GB model.
16β because I like the real estate.
64GB RAM because I came from 40GB in my iMac, and the closest option to that would have been 32GB, and I didnβt want to downgrade.
10-core, 32-core, 16-core because *speed* and *reasons*.
512GB SSD because I donβt want to spend money when I feel it’s overpriced. There are much, much, *much* cheaper, still reasonably fast external storage options available.
Choosing an external display
Hereβs where it got tricky β the choice wasnβt nearly as easy as choosing the Mac itself.
It’s confusing. Choose a screen size with the proper ppi, resolution, color definition, HDR… how should I connect it to my Mac? Should I use USB-C, HDMI or DisplayPort? Does the new M1 Mac support it properly? Will it work when connected to a Thunderbolt Dock?
And that’s only the beginning. There are trillions of monitors, from billions of companies. Samsung, Huawei, Sony, Philips, LG, ASUS, and Apple, only to name a few.
I excluded Appleβs XDR display right away, because Iβm not insane. Iβm not paying more for an external display than for the Mac. I don’t need the color accuracy, either. And yes, sure, I love retina displays, but not at all cost. Which also eliminated LGβs 5k monitor options. Not to mention, those are butt-ugly, and reportedly buggy.
So I had to look elsewhere.
I had the following criteria for a new monitor:
– at least 27β, 32β maximum
– at least 4k resolution
– IPS panel
– 10bit color (FRC or not, I don’t care)
– at least 400 nits
– not curved
– USB-C display data connection
– clean, no-bling-design with small bezels
– Not more than β or at max very close to β β¬1.000
– I didnβt care about reaction time. I believe that if I need a device mounted to my screen to measure 10ms vs 5ms vs 1ms, it just will not make any difference to my eyes at all and is just marketing to be able to charge more for it.
– I didn’t care about the displayβs power supply back to the Mac, as Iβd be using a Thunderbolt 4 Dock, which would take care of the charging for me.
– I didn’t care about any bling like LED ambience lighting or what the back of the display looked like. I find I’m more efficient at work looking at the front of my monitors, not at their backs.
– I didnβt care about, nor did I want, a built-in webcam. I rarely do video conferences, and when I do, Iβm using the MacBookβs built-in camera.
– I didn’t care about, nor did I want, internal speakers. I’m using AirPods most of the time, and when not, I’ll be using the MacBook Pro’s built-in speakers.Β
– I did care about ppi at first, because thereβs this often referenced and popular article saying that anything between ~115ppi and ~200ppi is βunusableβ on a Mac (Iβm paraphrasing and dramatising). But I changed my mind.Β I figured, Iβll be using the 4k screen scaled to 3.200×1.800, so it might not be that much of an issue. Turns out: it really isnβt. Using a 27″ 4k display scaled to 3.200×1.800 is just fine and I don’t see any artefacts like shown in that blog post. Itβs the same scaled resolution I used on the 27β 5k iMac, and though itβs obviously not as crisp, itβs very far from what Iβd consider bad or unusable or unsightly.
Your mileage may vary, but Iβd say: donβt worry about it. Itβll save you a ton of headaches. And I do have that nice liquid XDR MacBook Pro screen for when it really matters, so π€·ββοΈ.
Anyway, my criteria yielded a few options (in no particular order):
– LG UltraFine 27UN880-B
– Huawei MateView
– Philips 279C9
– HP 32
– Dell UltraSharp U3219Q
My tip for getting a new monitor: donβt read too many customer reviews. Thereβs pros and cons to anything, and it’ll just make you insecure about what to buy. It did me.
So yes, I did go down the rabbit hole of reading reviews for each of them and I couldnβt come to any conclusion. Features some people call a godsend others will call the worst thing since the butterfly keyboards.
All those reviews ironically led me to a monitor I couldnβt find almost no reviews for: the Philips 279C9. So it felt like the choice really was mine. And those thin bezels are π.
And just as I was about to order it, I found photos of it in use, and the uniformity of the background lighting was shockingly bad.
Plus, that monitor stand (though useful, as it allows you to rotate the screen) is too big and βnot prettyβ for my tastes. Yes, the monitor itself can be VESA mounted, but why pay for the included stand if Iβm not going to use it?
I then took a closer look at the Huawei MateView 28β.
The screen has a ratio of 16:10, which makes it higher than the others, with a 3.840x2560px β4k+β resolution. It also looks very βMac-likeβ, with its aluminium frame and silver appearance. But there were two caveats for me: For one, some cables come out at the side of the base, not the back. Ew. Secondly, I read that the resolution might give you metaphorical headaches with some game engines, and though Iβm currently too busy to be playing games on my Mac, I might want to in the future, or connect a Nintendo Switch or Sony PlayStation, and want it to just work. Thus, another option down.
Regarding the Dell monitors, I read they had trouble with burn-in/ghosting, and staying connected to the Mac. Buh-bye.
The HP monitor looked good at first sight, until I noticed that big border at the bottom, and the standby light in the front at the lower right. Ew again.
Which left me with the LG UltraFine 27UN880-B. And I have to say: itβs a choice I don’t regret one bit. I love it.
It checked all the marks on my list (and more, considering the ergonomics).
I was in luck, too: I bought it around Black Friday, so I got a nice discount.
Its most obvious feature is its ergonomic stand, which is mounted to the desk using a C-clamp. It is, indeed, very ergonomic and allows you to tilt, rotate, pivot and turn.
I was in bad luck, too: It didnβt work with my desk, as I found out after purchasing it. π€¦ββοΈ
Up until then, Iβd been using a glass desk. And thatβs the first red flag right there. In the monitorβs manual, it says not to use the c-clamp with desks made of fragile materials, like glass.
Now, this is thick glass weβre talking about here, but still, in the back of my mind, it bothered and worried me. I wouldnβt want to wake up one day only to find the MacBook Pro, the monitor, the desk and everything else on it shattered on the floor.
The final nail in the coffin for my glass desk, however, was that, at the back of the glass desk, thereβs this metal beam to enforce the entire frame.
When I purchased the monitor, I had hoped the C-clamp would just about fit. Well… it didn’t.
However, there was a silver lining. I had always wanted to get an electrical sit/stand desk.
This was the perfect opportunity to get one, which led me to
Choosing a new desk
From my last trip to IKEA years ago, I remembered they had a few electrical and mechanical standing desk options.
I didnβt want to get a mechanical one, so the βBekant” desk was the option for me. The P-shape and sheer size of it intrigued me, and the light wood finish is beautiful.
I briefly looked at fullyβs Jarvis desks, but they’re smaller, at around the same price as the IKEA one.
UPLIFTβs desks were another option, but assembling my own desk β and they offer tons of options β was beyond what I wanted to do.
So I trusted my gut and got the IKEA Bekant desk, and I adore it. It wasnβt cheap, but I thought of it as an investment in my health.
Sitting 10+ hours at my desk all day (which Iβve been doing for longer than I care to remember) canβt be good, so switching it up every now and then by standing up is very nice and, if nothing else, makes me *feel* healthier.
At the bottom of the desk plate, you can mount up the included mesh net, which can hold all your cables, power adapters, and power strips. So I have just one cable going from the desk to the outlet in the wall. Neat.
Choosing a Thunderbolt 4 Dock
My goal was to have all my peripherals (the monitor, my iPad, iPhone and 5 external disks) connected to the MacBook Pro with just one cable, and use that cable to charge it at the same time.
There arenβt too many Thunderbolt 4 Docks on the market yet, so I had two good options:
– OWC Thunderbolt 4 Dock
– CalDigit Thunderbolt 4 Element Hub
The OWC one was out of stock, and only has 3 USB-A ports instead of the CalDigitβs 4, so I went with the CalDigit Element Hub. Itβs such a cute, compact device.
It has 4 USB-A 10Gbit/s ports, which can power devices with up to 7.5W (so I can charge my iPad Pro, iPhone, AirPods, Keyboard, Mouse and Trackpad), and 3 Thunderbolt 4 ports which can power devices with up to 15W.
The 4th, upstream Thunderbolt 4 port, which goes into the Mac, delivers power of 60W. A little on the low side (which had me worried and wanting the OWC one, which delivers 90W), but, as it turns out, plenty to keep the MacBook Pro charged during my normal work day. Gaming surely will use more power, but discharging the battery from time to time is a good thing, so Iβm happy.
Another wish I had was to have one single cable to charge my iPad, iPhone, AirPods, and βMagic” input devices, so I got the Amazon Basics USB-A to C cable (10Gbit), and a USB-C to Lightning adapter, which allows for charging and synchronisation (plus on-device debugging in Xcode).
Alternatively, there’s Zaggβs 3-in-1 charging cable, but my question regarding whether it supported 10Gbit data transfer rates wasnβt answered in time. Alas, they’ve since responded, and it does support 10Gbit data transfer rates for the USB-C and USB-A part, and data for Lightning. Had I known beforehand, Iβd probably have purchased that one instead.
Putting it all together
Now that I had the new Mac, a monitor, a TB 4 Dock, a charging/data cable for the iPad and iPhone, and a new desk, it was time to put it all together.
The IKEA Bekant desk I put together in maybe an hour, one and a half, tops. It was really easy to do, which is what Iβve come to expect from IKEA furniture, and my girlfriend was so kind to help me get it into position – that is definitely a two-person job.
Transitioning from sitting to standing position (or vice-versa) is very smooth and doesn’t make too much of a noise. It doesn’t wobble and feels stable and sturdy.
For the LG monitor, I ordered two cheap steel plates to reinforce the area where the C-clamp clamps down on the desk, in order to protect it. Itβs likely unnecessary, but I want this to last for a long time.
I wanted the external monitor in front of me, as itβs my main display. Where I’d put the MacBook Pro was another question. At first, I had the MacBook to the left of the monitor.
As you can see, itβs a bit too close to the edge of the desk for comfort, so I moved it to the front of my monitor.
I liked it because it afforded me the opportunity to declutter my desk a bit, as I no longer needed the Magic Keyboard and Trackpad.
On the other hand, it meant that I had to move the iPad I had in front of the external display off to the side. With the iPad in front of me, it was easier to use with the Apple Pencil, and I could have it as a third screen for my Mac via SideCar when need be. It just made it more accessible to me in general.
So I moved the MacBook Pro off to the right, elevated it again with the Griffin Elevator, and put the iPad back in front of the monitor, which is the way I’m using it all now.
Hereβs the desk from the back side:
Sure enough, Iβve set it up so I donβt see all the cables or disks when I sit/stand at the desk.
However, from the back, itβs a mess. And I donβt care π€£
Caveats and other observations
As with any change, there’s potential for frustrations and unforeseen issues.
Considering the amount of change that has happened here, theyβre all minor ones, but perhaps still worthy of a mention.
The M1 Max MacBook Pro and external USB-C SSDs
Perhaps the most noteworthy and puzzling one is an issue Iβve noticed with external SSDs and the MacBook Pro.
On my older Intel iMac from 2017, I was receiving read/write speeds of around 340 MB/s. On this new MacBook Pro, I get around 240 MB/s (and thereβs no change whether the SSD is connected to the Mac directly or through the CalDigit Dock).
Itβs not a deal-breaker, as I donβt do much work off those drives (and even when I do, 240 MB/s is plenty for text work, which programming basically is). But I wonder where those ~100 MB/s went.
CalDigit Element Hub and charging the iPad Pro and iPhone
Whenever I charge my iPad Pro (and sometimes the iPhone) and it reaches around 94%, I pretty regularly get an error message that USB Accessories have been disabled.
Sometimes re-connecting works, sometimes it doesnβt. Iβve downloaded and installed CalDigitβs kernel extension which is supposed to help with this, but it isnβt loaded automatically into the kernel on power up, so I have to do it manually in Terminal, and even then, it doesnβt always help. Itβs a minor annoyance, but an annoyance nonetheless.
Amazon Basic USB-A-to-C cable
It works nicely (the Basevs Lightning Adapter too), but the braided cable is a bit stiff.
IKEA Bekant front edge is slightly receding
The cut-out at the front of the desk is slightly receding to the back of the desk, instead of being parallel to it.
(Am I explaining this correctly?)
It’s nit-picky and not a big deal, but I’d have preferred it to be parallel to the back edge.
With those nits being picked, I couldn’t be happier with the new setup!
I hope you all have a great and prosperous new year!
Take care of yourselves!
– Matthias